Ireland has joined 22 other countries in calling for a commitment to move away from fossil fuels to be restored to the proposed COP31 agreement, as Panama threatens to block a deal and small island states warn that the summit in Antalya could end in failure.
The talks are due to finish today. The latest draft acknowledges that global warming is expected to exceed 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels and that some of the damage could be irreversible. Yet it makes no mention of coal, oil or gas.
Three years ago in Dubai, countries agreed to transition away from fossil fuels in their energy systems. Monday’s draft in Antalya urged them to move faster on that promise. A second paragraph went further and called for fossil fuels to be phased out. Both paragraphs disappeared from the version published yesterday.
At a briefing this morning, Dutch climate minister Stientje van Veldhoven named Ireland among the countries seeking the return of the Dubai wording.
Ireland was represented by Oonagh Buckley, Secretary General of the Department of Climate, Energy and the Environment. Ireland and Tuvalu are to co-host next year’s international conference on how countries can make that transition.
The willingness of governments to challenge oil-producing countries in public has been evident at successive summits. In Belém last year, more than 80 countries backed a roadmap for moving away from fossil fuels, although it was left out of the final agreement. In Antalya, Panama has put in writing what it is prepared to do if it considers the deal too weak.
Its environment minister, Juan Carlos Navarro, has told the presidency that Panama will formally object at the closing session to a deal it cannot support. Among its eight demands are a cap on global oil production at current levels and a requirement for oil-producing countries to contribute climate finance.
COP agreements are reached by consensus, which gives Panama’s warning particular weight.
The 39-member Alliance of Small Island States described overshooting 1.5°C as “an unacceptable consequence of the advancement of profit over people” and said it “will not acquiesce to further inaction at this COP”.
It also wants governments to put a figure on their promise to triple funding to help developing countries adapt to climate change.
Yesterday’s draft still leaves open the question of what sum is to be tripled.
At a separate briefing, Tasneem Essop of Climate Action Network International urged governments, particularly those in the Global South, to reject the draft.
Mohamed Adow of Power Shift Africa described Antalya as “the worst COP ever”.
Former president Mary Robinson told RTÉ’s Morning Ireland that the EU should refuse to accept the removal of the fossil fuel wording.
Mrs Robinson, who is a founding member of The Elders, said removing the reference to fossil fuels is a “red line”, which ” just undermines the credibility of the whole thing if it’s not possible to get reference to what is causing the harm.”
“There’s reference to overshoot and then there’s no reference to what is actually causing the harm, that makes no sense”, she added.
Mrs Robinson said that the “COP is becoming a kind of place where there is a convening and there are good action agenda points and good voluntary commitments made and then smaller roadmaps of countries that are willing to go forward.”
She said science is needed “to guide us, but we also need leadership”, adding that under Ireland’s presidency of the EU, “we can have that leadership”.
The presidency argues that increasing electricity’s share of the energy the world uses, from about 23% today to 35% by 2035, would help deliver the Dubai promise.
One issue now is whether countries will agree both to use more electricity and to name the fuels it is meant to replace.
Read More:
‘The beach by my house does not exist anymore’
‘Kids drop out of school due to issues with water access’
‘The extraction industry is virtually killing the water’
‘Flash floods in Nepal swept away my family’s home’
‘Metres of our land is being stolen by sea level rise’
Nations had agreed at COP28 in 2023 to transition away from fossil fuels, but subsequent COP meetings have failed to make that target more specific or ambitious.
The draft text would also mark the first time a COP cover decision has explicitly acknowledged that global warming is projected to exceed the Paris Agreement’s 1.5 degrees Celsius threshold.
It said nations acknowledged “that the global transition towards low greenhouse gas emissions and climate-resilient development is irreversible.”
It also encouraged efforts to scale up the deployment of technologies that can suck carbon out of the atmosphere, something scientists say would be needed to bring temperatures back down.
Mrs Robinson said that despite the negatives, she still has hope.
“I have hope because I see so many great people, including at COPs, and they’re right across the board. They’re young climate activists, they’re women leaders, they’re business leaders, they’re scientists, they’re farmers, they’re fishers.”
“I’m always hopeful. I’m a prisoner of hope.”
Her comments come as the UN’s COP31 climate talks entered their endgame today, as negotiators from nearly 200 countries struggled to bridge their differences after two weeks of intense talks, which could spill into the weekend.
“At this point, no one is happy,” Brazil’s national secretary for climate change, Aloisio Lopes Pereira de Melo, told reporters with only hours before the conference’s official end.
The talks come with a series of stark reminders of the urgency of climate action, from heatwaves in Europe and devastating floods in Nepal to a record-breaking El Nino wreaking more havoc around the world.
But expectations of a major breakthrough have been low at COP31 as countries cope with an oil price shock and geopolitical tensions stemming from the war in Iran.
An EU official, speaking on condition of anonymity, said that the latest draft was “not acceptable and not ambitious enough”.
“We don’t want this COP to become a ‘fossil’ COP,” the official said.
Additional reporting AFP

