Worker blamed when monitors had to be scrapped wins €8k

worker-blamed-when-monitors-had-to-be-scrapped-wins-e8k

A technician sacked by a medical devices plant after his “tweaked” settings on a machine were blamed for the scrapping of $42,000 worth of insulin monitors has won two month’s salary for unfair dismissal but failed in a bid to get his job back.

The Workplace Relations Commission found that Seamus Sexton contributed “significantly” to his dismissal from Sanmina Ireland ULC in the wake of the July 2024 incident.

An adjudicator found the company had conducted an unfair disciplinary process, in part because it failed to properly examine the technician’s contention that he was under pressure to keep production running – a claim denied by the firm.

The company, which employs 440 making medical devices at a plant in Fermoy, Co Cork, submitted that problems were discovered with a July 2024 batch of under-the-skin monitoring devices used to measure blood sugar and insulin levels.

Nearly 14,677 of the implants in the bad batch had already been shipped, with compromised product worth $42,669.89 recalled from a customer and scrapped, it was submitted.

Two more batches still at the plant were also affected, the WRC was told.

The company traced the issue to pressure settings on a clamp used in a handling system on the production line for the monitors, the WRC was told.

The upper clamp pressure limit in the machine’s control system was meant to be set to 2.8 bar, but was actually set one fifth of one atmosphere higher, at 3.0 bar, it was submitted.

Logs noted five changes to the clamp pressure settings between 10 July 2024 and 18 July that year – but there were no records of any changes on the firm’s maintenance forms, the WRC was told.

Mr Sexton confirmed he was responsible for the pressure changes when he was asked about them.

Mr Sexton said in evidence that there was a “push” for more productivity at the plant in the year up to his dismissal.

He said that to deal with halts on the line, the technicians “tweaked” the machines without procedures being followed.

In this case, he said, he forgot to “put it back”. It was a “commonplace” practice in Sanmini, and something he he never thought he would be sacked for, he said.

The respondent relied on the complainant’s statement that he “cooperated fully, apologised, and accepted that the pressure change shouldn’t have happened”.

Cross-examining Mr Sexton, James Cleary of Ibec, for the respondent, said that if technicians were operating outside regulatory standards it would have been impossible for Sanmina to pass audits.

Mr Sexton said staff did not report the alleged practice to auditors because they “did not want to incriminate” their employer.

He called himself “the only fool that was caught”.

Mr Cleary submitted that there had been a full review which found no other settings were changed on the machines.

Mr Sexton was dismissed for gross misconduct, defined by the firm as “negligently operating equipment, tools or other devices” on 6 August 2024, a sanction upheld on internal appeal, the WRC heard.

The disciplinary officer, head of engineering Damien Collins, said it was a repeat infraction with “serious implications for patient safety”, and he “could not stand over” letting Mr Sexton go back to the workplace.

At the time of a hearing in December 2025, Mr Sexton said, he had not succeeded in finding new work, and sought reinstatement as a potential remedy. This was opposed by his former employer.

His representative, HR consultant John Walsh, said the investigation and disciplinary process was “shoddy and unprofessional” and that his client was treated in an “inhumane” manner.

In a decision published this week by the WRC, adjudicator Patricia Owens found that Sanmina “did not conduct a fair process”, and ruled the dismissal unfair.

She awarded Mr Sexton €8,236, two months’ salary, for the breach of the Unfair Dismissals Act 1977.

Mr Sexton had “contributed significantly to his own dismissal” and made “minimal” efforts to find new work,” the adjudicator wrote.

‘Mixed messages’

Ms Owens considered the investigation and disciplinary process unnecessarily “hasty” and found Mr Sexton was denied adequate time to prepare. There were “mixed messages” from the company leaving Mr Sexton “not fully appreciating the potential impact” of what was going on, she added.

He was denied a chance to challenge the information relied upon in the investigation report findings, and there was no evidence that mitigating factors Mr Sexton raised were “fully examined and considered”, she wrote.

“His suggestion that the practice of adjusting the machine was commonplace was dismissed, and his concern regarding work pressure was also dismissed,” Ms Owens wrote.

She noted further that Sanmina registered the termination of Mr Sexton’s employment with Revenue four days prior to his dismissal – leading her to conclude the decision to sack him was already made before the final disciplinary meeting.

She had questioned Mr Collins, the disciplinary officer, about what Mr Sexton had said about being under pressure at the time.

“Pressure is pressure,” Mr Collins said in response.

He said this claim was examined and the conclusion reached was that “the pressure on productivity was not abnormal… and certainly not a reason to put patients at risk”.

“No other staff member had ever changed settings to achieve a higher output,” he said.

Leave a Reply