World order changing, not rupturing, finance chiefs say

The world order is changing but not enduring a rupture, finance leaders said today, pushing back on Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney’s narrative that a ⁠new order, driven by major power coercion, was taking shape.

In his speech at Davos, Carney called on nations to accept that a rules-based global order was over and great powers were abandoning even the pretence of following internationa lagreements.

Quoting ancient Greek historian Thucydides, Carney said the world was entering a period in which “the strong can do what they can and the weak must suffer what they must”.

“I’m not exactly on the same page as Mark,” European Central Bank President Christine Lagarde told the World Economic Forumin Davos today, just days after Carney’s appearance.

“I’m not sure that we should be talking about rupture,” she said.

“I think we should be talking about alternatives. We should be identifying, much more so than we have probably in the past, the weaknesses, the sore points, the dependencies, the autonomy,” she added.

“We’re not in Kansas anymore’

World Trade Organization chief Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala said that uncertainty was unlikely to remain as high as this month, when US President Donald Trump threatened to take over Greenland from NATO ally Denmark.

But the old order ⁠was also not going to return, uncertainty would linger and countries must invest in their own resilience, she said.

“I don’t think we’ll go back to where we were. ⁠But they will not be as bad and maybe we’ll have a slightly better, steady state for the future,” Okonjo-Iweala said.

“If I was running a country, I’d be trying to strengthen myself ⁠and my region, ⁠and I’d be looking at my region and then building resilience,” she added.

Kristalina Georgieva, the International Monetary Fund’s director, argued that change was natural and has been happeningfor years, and it was time to embrace this because shocks would keep happening.

“We are not in Kansas, anymore,” she ⁠said, referencing a line in the Wizard of Oz, meaning that the comforts of familiar surroundings were gone for good.

Lagarde, who walked out of a Davos dinner during a speech critical of Europe by US Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick earlier this week, was in a more forgiving mood today.

“We have heard quite a lot of European-bashing in the last few days, but if anything, it has been good, and we should say ‘thank you’ to the bashers, because I think it has given us a complete realisation of the fact that we have to be morefocused; ⁠we have to work on those plans B,” she told the Davos gathering.